top of page

Short Sale vs. Foreclosure: Financial Hardship in Texas!

(Both the video and article offer distinct perspectives and information. Be sure to check out both for a comprehensive understanding. The video provides visual clarity, while the article delves into specific details. Together, they provide valuable insights to help you navigate your situation effectively.)

When financial difficulties make it impossible to keep up with your mortgage payments in Texas, two options emerge: a short sale or foreclosure. Both aim to resolve the situation, but they differ significantly in how they impact you and your property.

Considering either option of a short sale or foreclosure often stems from being overwhelmed by mortgage payments due to job loss, medical bills, or unexpected circumstances, which can swiftly transform homeownership from a source of stability to a financial burden. Moreover, grappling with an underwater mortgage, where the home's value falls below the outstanding mortgage balance, presents a formidable obstacle to selling and moving forward.

In Texas, both a foreclosure and a short sale will negatively impact your credit score, but to varying degrees and durations. Here's a breakdown:


  • Impact: Devastating impact on your credit score, potentially dropping it by hundreds of points.

  • Duration: Remains on your credit report for 7 years from the date of the first missed payment that led to foreclosure.

Short Sale:

  • Impact: Still negatively impacts your credit score, but typically not as severely as a foreclosure. The score may drop, but the decrease is usually less significant.

  • Duration: Also remains on your credit report for 7 years, but from the date the short sale is finalized.

Here's a table summarizing the key differences:



Short Sale

Credit Score Impact


Less Severe

Duration on Credit Report

7 years from 1st missed payment

7 years from short sale finalization

Additional Considerations:

  • Recovery Time: You may be able to recover your credit score from a short sale within 2-4 years with responsible financial management. Foreclosure recovery typically takes longer.

  • Tax Implications: In a short sale, forgiven debt from the lender may be considered taxable income. Consult with a tax advisor for specifics.

While both options leave a mark on your credit, a short sale offers a potentially less damaging path compared to foreclosure. Working with a qualified real estate agent experienced in Texas short sales can significantly improve your chances of a successful outcome, minimizing the negative impact on your credit and future financial opportunities.

Now, let's dive into the key differences: Control Over the Process:

Short Sale: You have more control. You work with a realtor to find a buyer and negotiate the sale price with the lender. This allows some flexibility and a chance to potentially influence the outcome.

Foreclosure: The lender takes control. They initiate legal action, repossess the property, and sell it through an auction. You have no say in the selling price or process.

In a short sale, there's a chance the lender might forgive what's left of what you owe after the sale. However, it's not guaranteed, and it depends on how negotiations go. With foreclosure, you're on the hook for paying back the difference between what the house sells for and what you still owe on the mortgage. This is called the deficiency balance, and if you can't pay, the lender might take legal action against you.

Here are some lesser-known facts about short sales and foreclosures during divorce or legal troubles in Texas:

Short Sale:

  • Spousal Cooperation:  In Texas, if you're jointly responsible for the mortgage (both names are on the title and loan), cooperation from your spouse is crucial for a successful short sale. You'll both need to sign off on the short sale agreement with the lender.

  • Tax Implications for Both Spouses:  If the lender forgives a portion of the debt in a short sale, that forgiven amount may be considered taxable income for both spouses, even if only one spouse's name is on the tax return. Consulting with a tax advisor is essential to understand the potential tax implications for both parties involved in the divorce.

  • Impact on Ability to Buy a New Home (Especially After Divorce):  A short sale can still negatively impact your ability to qualify for a new mortgage, especially soon after the sale. This can be a challenge for divorced couples who need to purchase separate homes.


  • Court Involvement in Divorce May Affect Foreclosure Timeline:  If the property is part of the divorce settlement, the court may need to approve any foreclosure proceedings. This can add complexity and extend the timeline compared to a typical foreclosure.

  • Deficiency Judgment and Impact on Future Assets:  Even if you and your spouse are no longer living together, a deficiency judgment from a foreclosure can still affect your future assets. In Texas, the lender can potentially seize other assets (depending on state exemptions) to recover the remaining balance after the foreclosure sale.

  • Emotional Toll During Divorce:  The already stressful process of divorce can be significantly exacerbated by the added pressure and emotional strain of foreclosure.

When considering either a short sale or foreclosure, it's important to recognize that both can have lasting effects on future legal matters, including issues like child custody arrangements or alimony payments. Having a clear understanding of the financial implications before proceeding is vital. Seeking guidance from a knowledgeable lawyer specializing in divorce and real estate law is highly recommended. They can provide invaluable support, navigating the legal complexities, protecting your rights, and ensuring a fair outcome. Additionally, maintaining open and honest communication between spouses, even amid a divorce, is essential. This transparency ensures that everyone involved is aware of the potential consequences, enabling informed decision-making throughout the process.

Remember, every situation is unique. Consulting with qualified professionals like a real estate agent experienced in short sales, a tax advisor, and a lawyer specializing in divorce and real estate law is essential to make the best decision for your specific circumstances.

I hold certifications in both short sales and foreclosures, and I'm here to assist you with any inquiries you may have. Please feel free to reach out to me via email at Additionally, you're welcome to send me a text message—I'm available to help in any way I can!

"Divorces and financial challenges can be incredibly tough—each person may have a different perspective on how they ended up in this situation. Sometimes, one may feel upset, while the other may feel excited. Regardless of the emotions involved, I want to remind you both that this is just a moment in the beautiful life of your future. This season of endings will heal, and you will flourish once again."~~A.Allen

Amanda Allen, Realtor


(903) 603-0648


Hi, thanks for stopping by!

Thank you for taking the time to visit my blog. If you have any questions or if there is a real estate-related topic that you would like me to cover in a future blog post, please don't hesitate to let me know. I value your feedback and am always looking for ways to provide informative and engaging content for my readers. If you do suggest a topic that I end up writing about, I would be happy to give you credit for the suggestion.

Real Estate Questions

Thanks for submitting!

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Twitter
  • Pinterest
bottom of page